The restaurant business could not be more difficult or more trendy. When a new restaurant opens in any neighborhood, all foodies in the area want to try it out. Obviously, that takes some business away from the existing restaurants.
The same thing happens when there is a new trend or a chef with a fancy pedigree. Then there’s the craziness of working around the clock — including nights, weekends and holidays (when most sensible people are off) — with fingernail-thin margins, staff shortages, in extreme heat or cold, with every customer a critic on social media and fickle customers …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
You can also purchase this individual item for $1.50
We have recently launched a new and improved website. To continue reading, you will need to either log into your subscriber account, or purchase a new subscription.
If you are a digital subscriber with an active subscription, then you already have an account here. Just reset your password if you've not yet logged in to your account on this new site.
If you are a current print subscriber, you can set up a free website account by clicking here.
Otherwise, click here to view your options for subscribing.
Please log in to continue |
The restaurant business could not be more difficult or more trendy. When a new restaurant opens in any neighborhood, all foodies in the area want to try it out. Obviously, that takes some business away from the existing restaurants.
The same thing happens when there is a new trend or a chef with a fancy pedigree. Then there’s the craziness of working around the clock — including nights, weekends and holidays (when most sensible people are off) — with fingernail-thin margins, staff shortages, in extreme heat or cold, with every customer a critic on social media and fickle customers shifting alliances.
Therefore, to be approaching 30 years in business in 2027, as local landmark Chestnut Grill & Sidewalk Cafe is currently doing, is a Himalayan accomplishment, especially since the restaurant located inside the Chestnut Hill Hotel has flown below the radar for most of that time.
Recent visits have confirmed that the food is not adventurous and is not going to win any James Beard awards, but it is straightforward American food that is consistent, well prepared with fresh ingredients, affordable, and served in pleasant surroundings by efficient, friendly servers. And as former co-owner Greg Welsh once told the Local, “Chestnut Grill is the longest running restaurant in Chestnut Hill whose owners do not own the property.”
One thing I have always appreciated about Chestnut Grill is their offering vegetarian dishes long before it became more common. On this point, I would also like to mention The Blue Warbler, the very popular new restaurant at Willow Grove and Germantown avenues that also has lots of excellent vegetarian and seafood options.
Chestnut Grill owner/chef John Arena has always mined great flavors with his vegan chili ($8); he plays the seafood card like a Las Vegas dealer with the grilled New Orleans catfish marinated with Cajun aioli and scallions ($13.50); and the marinated grilled salmon skewers, a suite of enticing tastes with its miso drizzle, spicy noodles with peanuts, pepper sesame oil, red pepper, sesame seed scallion and rice vinaigrette salad greens ($13.50). Desserts leave you with a fond finish: house-made carrot cake with fresh carrots, walnuts, raisins, praline pecan filling, buttercream cheese frosting and toasted coconut ($9.50); warm upside-down peach pie baked with a brown sugar butter pecan crust and vanilla ice cream ($9.50).
Chestnut Grill was opened in July 1997 by partners Greg Welsh, John Arena and Pete Kelly. Welsh and Arena bought out Kelly, who left after two years to open North by Northwest in Mt. Airy with a partner, Ronald Berg. It closed in March 2009. Welsh and Arena also opened Stella Notte, the old Pollo Rosso spot on the second floor of the Chestnut Hill Hotel, in 2000. It closed in 2005.
Welsh, who was also president of the Chestnut Hill Business Association and founder of the now-defunct Chestnut Hill Book Festival, sold his share to Arena in 2018.
Arena graduated from Upper Dublin High School in Fort Washington in 1979 and Widener University in 1984 with a bachelor’s degree in hotel and restaurant management. He worked after college for eight different restaurants in the Stouffer chain from 1985 until 1997, when he helped open Chestnut Grill.
Chestnut Grill can seat 70 people on two outdoor patios, one in front of the hotel and one on the side. “For the first year-and-a-half of the pandemic, people just wanted outside,” said Arena in an earlier interview. Because he had to take out a substantial loan to keep the restaurant open, Arena said, the federal government’s Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) during the pandemic was critical. “Once the PPP money came in, we were confident we’d make it through,” he said.
“I had a wife and three young children to support when we opened here,” he added. “I quit my corporate restaurant job of 12 years to open the Grill. I took out a second mortgage on the equity in my house and used whatever savings I had. I was 35.”
One of the many attractions at Chestnut Grill is server Maksym Burych, who wears charm like a second skin. “Max” and his family — twin brother Zakhar, mom Liudmyla and dad Ivan, who had his own business in Ukraine selling agricultural products — were on vacation in Poland to celebrate Max’s upcoming 18th birthday on Feb. 19, 2022. They had planned to return to their home in Ukraine on Feb. 26. However, the Russians began their unprovoked, murderous assault on Feb. 24, 2022.
So rather than return home as planned, Max and his family came to the United States. They selected Philadelphia as their destination because Max’s mother, who was a stay-at-home mom in Ukraine, had a best friend who had come to Wyndmoor from Ukraine in 1996.
More information at 215-247-7570 or chestnuthillgrill.com. Len Lear can be reached at lenlear@chestnuthilllocal.com.